Xmega Shop
Game subscriptions changed more in the past year than in the previous three combined, so if you last compared these in 2024 the landscape looks different now.
Xbox Game Pass: new tier names, lower Ultimate price
Microsoft renamed its tiers in late 2025 — the old "Core" tier is now sold as Xbox Game Pass Core-equivalent entry access, and the top tier is Xbox Game Pass Ultimate, which includes console, PC, and cloud access plus EA Play and Ubisoft+ Classics bundled in. After a steep price increase when the tiers were restructured, Microsoft cut Ultimate's price again in April 2026 following subscriber pushback — worth knowing if you dropped the service after the original increase, since the value proposition has shifted back in buyers' favor. If you specifically want the PC-only tier, Xbox Game Pass for PC is priced separately from the console/cloud bundle.
PlayStation Plus: three tiers, unchanged structure
PlayStation Plus Essential covers online multiplayer and monthly free games. PlayStation Plus Extra adds a large game catalog. PlayStation Plus Premium/Deluxe adds game trials and classic titles via cloud streaming. Sony hasn't restructured these tiers the way Microsoft did, so the value comparison here is more stable year over year.
EA Play: the specialist option
EA Play is worth buying standalone specifically if you only care about EA's catalog (FIFA/EA FC, Madden, Battlefield early access) and don't want a full Game Pass or PS Plus subscription. EA Play Pro adds day-one access to new EA releases, which matters if you buy EA sports titles annually.
Check what left the library before resubscribing
Because all of these services rotate their catalogs, a game you remember being available a year ago may no longer be there — before resubscribing specifically to play something you saw mentioned previously, confirm it's still in the current library rather than assuming catalogs are static month to month.
Family sharing options differ meaningfully too — Xbox and PlayStation both support some form of sharing a subscription across a household, though the exact mechanics and limits (number of accounts, simultaneous play) vary and are worth checking directly against your household's actual usage pattern before assuming both work identically.
Trial periods for first-time subscribers are commonly offered across all three at a reduced introductory price — worth using a trial period to test the actual library and performance on your specific setup before committing to a full-price ongoing subscription.
Achievements and trophies earned while playing through a subscription service generally carry over normally to your platform profile the same as a purchased game, so switching from a subscribed title to owning it later (if you choose to buy it outright) doesn't reset progress already tracked.
Which one to actually buy
If you're on Xbox or PC and want the broadest day-one library, Xbox Game Pass Ultimate is now a stronger value than it was in late 2025 following the April 2026 price cut. If you're on PlayStation, Extra or Premium are the meaningful tiers over Essential. If you specifically only play EA sports titles, skip both and go straight to EA Play. Compare all current tiers in Gaming Subscriptions.